Nutrition

The Supplements Worth Your Money

The supplement aisle is full of promises. Here are the few with real evidence, the ones to test for first, and the ones to leave on the shelf.

Fish oil capsules, white capsules and small tablets scattered across a marble benchtop

The short version

  • Supplements only top up the basics – training, food and sleep do the heavy lifting
  • Protein powder, creatine and caffeine have the best evidence for training
  • Get your bloods checked before taking iron or vitamin D, and skip the fat burners and detox teas

I walked past a supplement shop the other day and counted the promises in the front window. Shred fat. Boost testosterone. Detox your liver. Unlock your energy. Burn belly fat while you sleep. If half of it worked, I’d be out of a job.

The supplement industry is enormous, and it’s very good at selling hope in a tub. So let’s cut through it. Here’s what’s actually worth your money, what you should test for before you buy, and what you can leave on the shelf.

Start with the pyramid

Before we talk about any pill or powder, picture a pyramid. At the bottom, the biggest part, is training consistently. Then eating well, with enough protein, fibre and plants. Then sleep and managing stress. Right up the very top, a tiny little tip, is supplements.

Most people try to build the pyramid upside down. They buy a fat burner before they’ve fixed their breakfast, or they’re taking six capsules a day while sleeping five hours a night.

Supplements are called supplements for a reason. They top up a good routine. They can’t replace one.

If the basics aren’t there yet, nothing in a tub will make up for it. I’d rather see you spend that money on fresh food. If they are, a few products might give you a small extra edge.

Worth considering

These are the ones with the most decent evidence behind them for people who train.

Protein powder. It isn’t magic, it’s just convenient protein. If you struggle to hit your protein from food, or you need something quick after a 6am session, a shake is a perfectly good tool. Whey is a solid choice, and there are good plant-based options too. I explain how to get there with food in Protein Without the Powder.

Creatine. One of the most studied supplements around. It helps you do a little more work in short, intense efforts, which adds up to more strength over time. Plain creatine monohydrate, 3–5 grams a day. I go deep on it in Creatine Isn’t Just for Bodybuilders.

Caffeine. Yes, your morning coffee counts. Caffeine has good evidence for improving performance and making hard sessions feel a bit easier. Your local café does the job just as well as a pre-workout powder, and usually with a lot less nonsense in it. More on that in Coffee Before Training: Help or Hype?.

Test, don’t guess

Some supplements only make sense if you’re actually low in something. Taking them “just in case” can be a waste of money, and some can cause problems if you take too much.

Vitamin D. We live in sunny Australia, but plenty of people who work indoors, cover up, have darker skin or are older can still end up low, especially in winter. If you’re deficient, a supplement can make a real difference. But get it checked first.

Iron. Low iron is common, particularly in women with heavy periods, vegetarians and endurance athletes, and it can leave you feeling flat and exhausted in training. But too much iron isn’t good for you either, so this is one where you really want a blood test before you start.

Others. Things like B12 for vegans, or omega-3s if you never eat fish, can be worth discussing too.

The answer for all of these is simple: book in with your GP, tell them how you’re feeling and how you train, and ask whether it’s worth checking your bloods. Then supplement based on the results, not on a post you saw online.

Leave them on the shelf

Fat burners. Most of them are a big hit of caffeine with some other ingredients thrown in, and a hefty price tag. They might make you feel jittery and sweaty, but sweat isn’t fat loss. Some have been found to contain ingredients that aren’t on the label, which is a real risk.

Detox teas and cleanses. Your liver and kidneys already do this job, and they do it for free. Most detox teas are laxatives with a nice label.

“Testosterone boosters.” For the vast majority of people, these don’t meaningfully change hormone levels. If you’re genuinely worried about your hormones, that’s a conversation for your GP, not the supplement shop.

BCAAs. If you’re eating enough protein, you’re already getting these amino acids. They’re largely a very expensive way to flavour your water.

Multivitamins. Not harmful at normal doses, but for most people eating a reasonable diet, a daily multi is unlikely to make a noticeable difference to how they train or feel. If your diet is patchy, the better fix is more variety on the plate, not another pill.

A note on labels

In Australia, many supplements are sold as “listed” medicines with an AUST L number. That number means the product has met certain safety and quality requirements, but it doesn’t mean anyone has checked that it actually does what it claims. Sports supplements sold as foods have even less oversight. So a professional-looking label is not proof it works.

If you compete in a drug-tested sport, only use products that have been independently batch tested. Contamination does happen.

And if you’re pregnant, take regular medication, or have a medical condition, check with your GP or pharmacist before adding anything new. Some supplements interact with medications.

Most of the money people spend on supplements would be better spent on good food, a decent pair of shoes or a few more training sessions. Get the bottom of the pyramid sorted first. Then, if you want an edge, protein powder, creatine and a coffee are about as far as most people need to go.

Not sure your protein is where it should be? Start with How Much Protein Do You Actually Need?

More on nutrition
Share
Samuel Degabriele

Written by

Samuel Degabriele

Owner & Head Coach

If you knew me at school, I was a chubby, overweight, shy kid who was always the last one picked for teams. I never liked sports, but during that time I discovered my outlet: weight training.

Your first week is on us

Become the best
you know you can be.

Register for a free 7-day trial. Meet the team, get a 30-minute movement screening and a program built around your body and your goals.

The Studio 84 coaches and members together on the gym floor
Book Free 7-day trial