Training

HIIT: How Hard Is Hard Enough?

Real HIIT is short, sharp and properly hard. Most people either go too easy or do it far too often. Here’s how to get it right.

A sweaty, exhausted man catching his breath on an exercise bike in a gym

The short version

  • The work intervals should feel genuinely hard – an 8 or 9 out of 10
  • The rest matters as much as the work, so take it
  • Two or three HIIT sessions a week is plenty for most people

HIIT has been one of the most popular ways to train for years now, and for good reason. It’s time-efficient, it builds fitness fast, and there’s something very satisfying about collapsing on the floor at the end of a session knowing you’ve given it everything.

We run Heroic HIIT at the studio and it’s one of our busiest classes. But here’s the thing. A lot of what gets called HIIT isn’t really HIIT at all. And a lot of people doing real HIIT are doing far too much of it.

So let’s talk about how hard “high intensity” actually needs to be, and how to get the most out of it.

What makes it HIIT

HIIT stands for high-intensity interval training. The idea is simple: short bursts of very hard work, separated by periods of rest or easy movement. The hard bursts push your heart, lungs and muscles close to their limit. The rest lets you recover enough to do it again.

The magic is in the contrast. Because you get to rest, you can work much harder in each interval than you could if you were going non-stop. That’s what drives the big fitness gains.

Where it often goes wrong is when a workout turns into 45 minutes of non-stop, medium-hard effort. It feels tough, you’re sweaty and puffed, but you’re never really going hard, and you’re never really recovering. That’s not HIIT. That’s just a long, tiring workout.

How hard is hard?

The easiest way to gauge it is a simple scale from 1 to 10, where 1 is sitting on the couch and 10 is an all-out sprint you couldn’t keep up for more than a few seconds.

For most HIIT work, the intervals should feel like an 8 or 9 out of 10. You can’t hold a conversation. You’re focused on getting to the end of the interval. When the timer goes, you’re genuinely glad to stop.

The length of the intervals changes how hard you can go:

  • Very short efforts (10–20 seconds) can be close to flat-out.
  • Medium efforts (30–60 seconds) should be very hard, but controlled enough that you don’t fall apart halfway.
  • Longer efforts (2–4 minutes) are hard but sustainable, more like an 8 out of 10.

If you finish an interval and feel like you could have kept going for another minute at the same pace, it probably wasn’t hard enough. If you’re falling apart by the second round, you’ve gone out too hot. Learning to pace yourself is part of the skill.

HIIT should feel hard because it’s short, not long because it’s hard.

The rest is part of the workout

People love to skip the rest. They think standing around for 30 seconds is wasted time, so they keep moving, or they shorten the break to feel more hardcore.

But the rest is what lets you hit the next interval properly. If you don’t recover enough, each round gets slower and sloppier, and the whole session drifts back into that medium-hard zone we’re trying to avoid.

So when the coach says rest, rest. Walk it off, get your breath back, sip some water and get ready to go again. Your next effort will be better for it.

How often should you do it?

This is where I see the biggest mistakes. Because HIIT works so well, people figure more must be better. So they do it five or six days a week.

The problem is that real high-intensity work is demanding on your body. Your muscles, joints and nervous system need time to recover from it. Do too much, too often, and you end up tired, sore and flat, with performance going backwards instead of forwards.

For most people, two or three HIIT sessions a week is plenty. Fill the rest of your week with:

  • Strength training to build and keep muscle.
  • Easier cardio, like walking, cycling or a steady jog. (I explain why in Zone 2 Training, Explained.)
  • Mobility and recovery work to keep you moving well.

That mix gives you the benefits of HIIT without burning yourself out. And because you’re fresher, the HIIT sessions you do will be higher quality.

Getting the most out of a HIIT session

A few things that make a big difference:

  • Warm up properly. Going hard on cold muscles is a recipe for a pulled hammy. Give yourself 10 minutes to build up.
  • Choose the right exercises. Bikes, rowers, sleds, skipping and simple bodyweight moves are great. Complex, technical lifts are not ideal when you’re exhausted.
  • Keep your form. If your technique starts falling apart, slow down or scale the movement. Getting injured is the fastest way to lose fitness.
  • Work to your level. Your 8 out of 10 is different to the person next to you. Don’t try to match them. Just make sure you’re working hard for you.
  • Cool down. A few minutes of easy movement helps your heart rate come down gradually.

If you’ve got a heart condition, a history of injury or you’ve been inactive for a while, have a chat to your GP before you jump into high-intensity training. Then ease in. Start with fewer intervals and longer rests, and build up over a few weeks.

In the end, the best HIIT session isn’t the longest one or the one that leaves you lying on the floor for the longest time. It’s the one where you work genuinely hard, recover properly and walk out feeling like you’ve done something worthwhile.

Do that two or three times a week, alongside your strength work and some easier movement, and you’ll be amazed at how fast your fitness improves.

If you’ve never tried a coached HIIT class, the free 7-day trial is a great way to give Heroic HIIT a go.

Not sure how sore you should feel the next day? Read Sore Today, Stronger Tomorrow?

More on training
Share
Samuel Degabriele

Written by

Samuel Degabriele

Owner & Head Coach

If you knew me at school, I was a chubby, overweight, shy kid who was always the last one picked for teams. I never liked sports, but during that time I discovered my outlet: weight training.

Your first week is on us

Become the best
you know you can be.

Register for a free 7-day trial. Meet the team, get a 30-minute movement screening and a program built around your body and your goals.

The Studio 84 coaches and members together on the gym floor
Book Free 7-day trial